Andrew it was a couple comments on FLYGUY but anyways....
On the ethanol plant, you sound like you are regurgitating information not sharing an opinion. First off, the fact that the grain silos are still standing is a symbol of why Buffalo is in rough shape. Holding on to the past is the best way to prevent the future. They should have been knocked down.
Now I know you are in school so the world is still not discovered by you but here is the reality of the situation. As someone from the sticks of Holland who has adopted Buffalo from a dorm room, you really should have more respect for the 1st ward. But you are a child and I digress.
If the ethanol plant goes up you can pretty much shoot down any development of the outer harbor and the 1st ward. These two areas provide the vast tracks of land that can be redeveloped with ease and serve as the gateway to a new Buffalo. Take a look at the map kid. The only way for the outer harbor to happen is for all signs of industry to be removed, including things like the GM plant and working Ethanol plants/empty grain silos. Now maybe when you went on vacation with mommy and daddy you realized that hotel rooms are booked on view. No hotel is going to build on the water provided half of it's view is of rail yards, ethanol plants and the like. Oh yea, Marriott and Hilton also will consider smell and rats to be a problem.
Buffalo needs to consolidate its industry/rail and brown fields. Allowing this NEW operation prevents this consolidation. Without this consolidation, it becomes virtually impossible for wide spread land to be reclaimed for uses other then industry. ALL OF THIS FOR 80 JOBS. Yep, that sounds smart. Typical Buffalo...Short term gain for long term loss.
As for the brain drain. Get out of college and see the real world before you comment. Yes Buffalo has close to 70K college students but most are from outside of Buffalo and will not stay. For those who are from the area, the smartest students most likely are attending schools outside of WNY and will not come back. For those we went local, they most likely will need to move unless the basement of mommy and daddy has a vacancy sign. Remember we are talking about %'s of thousands of kids not your group of friends that goes to Coles every Tuesday.
As for 1000 back office jobs, of course they will get filled. It is only 1000 jobs. It is only one employer. Now I know you are a confident kid but before you start discrediting proven trends like population shifts and the brain drain, I suggest you grow your resume of living experience to more then the farms of Holland and Elmwood Ave.
If you want to see why the brain drain exists, look up science/biotech jobs. Look up marketing/advertising/PR jobs. Look up Business Management jobs. Compare the listings of these jobs in Buffalo to other parts of the US. Or wait until you get out of school to understand that 900 of the 1000 back office jobs at citi group are not what mommy and daddy paid 4 years at Canisius for. Instead of looking at the jobs that college kids would jump all over, add 5 years of experience to your resume, a new wife and a kid on the way. Now think how well these jobs pay when you are competing with college kids who just want to bust their fist nut.
Report this