An Elmwood Moment; A Stop, a Pause; and a Dream that Could Be – Stuyvesant Plaza

An Elmwood Moment; A Stop, a Pause; and a Dream that Could Be – Stuyvesant Plaza

Story Options

Stopped by the UPS store at the Stuyvesant’s Plaza on Elmwood today. I love that store; it’s quick and excellent service; and I depend on its copy service every summer when we run our sailing school in Buffalo. So I felt horribly bad that dear Joe passed away who ran it. Daughters Lyn and her sister explained he passed away at Christmas. Heart Attack. Sudden and done. I learned of this sad news as I was requesting a large, last minute job order. Lyn told me, with a wink of the eye, “It’s you people, Bill, who come in here and want copies at last minute, leave the folders and expect to come back in minutes and it’s done…” I understood what she was saying, as Joe really did accomplish miracles. We’ll miss him. God Bless him.

In the end, I got my sailing course copies and was in a hurry to get back to Seven Seas Sailing School. Suddenly, though, I wasn’t in a hurry.

Standing beside my car, I looked out over the plaza, at all of its tenants: HR Block, Cricket, UPS and Lockman, and the gaping, ornate brick entry of the huge and empty Latino’s Market. Suddenly I’m sweating there in the hot sun, staring at this vast plaza and wondering. Curiosity grows, and I think about its back North Street parking lot that in any other city would be the most luxuriating inner city parkland but has for over a decade or more been totally empty asphalt paving yet with no cars and no use.

Thoughts and memories began to stir. What could this place become next? It’s empty after Latino’s left, after ‘Poor Quality Market’ left, after Bells and Loblaws and A&P left. What’s next? Location, Location, Location is the rule. So how about a robo paint blast recreation theater? No; no thanks; please no thanks. How about the world’s largest box-store tattoo parlor? Again, please, no thanks. How about another food store, another one, you know...another one? Likely, but no thanks.

But then I got thinking and remembering something…and the structure of the plaza complex had me glued.

Back, a couple sailing seasons ago we sailed to Toronto, and on the Sunday morning visited a place next to the Hockey Museum downtown Toronto called something like Movenpick’s Village.

Anyway, this place was cool. We were variously sailor-scrubby, very hungry, and had some mix of US and Canadian dollars on us, very ready to eat a cow. It was about noon. We went inside, grabbed our “menu tickets” which included a pen to honestly record what we chose from the indoors village vendors… we ambled together as a group but quickly split up into our various desires—one went for egg omelets served at a stand that was old village superb; even the cook was in character and verve. Others went for the vintner table’s delights of Canadian wines being served for that day’s village brunch. Still others of us sailors grabbed croissants, beef dishes, ham and more. The variety of cheeses and breads were ultimate “go for it” material.

We agreed we’d never seen a place like this—part Broadway Market, part aggrandized Disney village aura, all under one roof. You could eat cheap, or rich, all under one venue, community-friendly, with a taste of the history scent and all.

So that got me thinking—and this of course is only a dream—what if some developer in Buffalo took this lease from Benchmark and made a grand village scenario eatery, complete with shops at all ends, Junior League and Allentown and Elmwood shops all endeavored to assign efforts?

What if this place could be a Buffalo Village Emporium, a new day market sort of place? Get some big buck and little buck transcendancy to its spirit. Build a cadre of retail merchant believers. Open seven days a week with an inside village atmosphere. There’s more than enough parking on both sides. The front entrance on Elmwood could spirit several flower efforts and the back parking lot could hold glorious outside eatery patios and even a GEX-style nature’s flea market with all kinds of wares. Buckets of trees could sprout up and beds of flowers and chairs for people to sit and enjoy. There’d still be more parking than anyone would need.

So let’s be energetic about the options and talk about it. That’s what we’re here for, as a community, to talk about it, isn’t it? There’s a dream there. Go check it out. Talk and discourse and even argue about it but let’s cheer some new good needed change there.

prometheus233.com half banner

What Others Have To Say

  1. icecreamsub

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 8th 2007, 13:18

    definately mix use of something: day market, skate park....maybe Dash's Market. Good thing a Walgreens is too close for the thought of adding another mega drug store.

  2. mjm

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 8th 2007, 13:39

    I love the idea of using that space as a Broadway Market type of place. It would be really cool if there were some semi-enclosed structures added onto the existing building in the rear parking lot for a farmer's market kind of thing for produce... like Cleveland's west side market.

  3. UprightCitizen

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 8th 2007, 13:54

    first, thanks for acknowledging the fine folks who run the UPS store. an old fashioned family business at its best.

    second, you efficiently detail the disappointing history of supermarkets at that address. the Barcelona family's renovation of the premises (expanding the store's footprint and decimating houses and yards to create the rear parking lot) is a violation of civic trust. that space should be returned to the public as a park (he said quixotically).

    the neighborhood surrounding Stuyvesant needs a food market.

    let me expand. EVERY neighborhood needs a food market where locals can walk to for reasonably priced, fresh, quality groceries and household basics.

    It is amazing that every store at that location has failed. It is equally amazing that each store (and I have shopped them all) each offered a weak inventory (limited selection, mediocre quality, variable reliability items would be in stock). However, no matter how spotty the shelves, each business was badly, badly managed. Never enough help. Undertrained service help. Lax security. I have had to check my shoulder bag on at rush shopping hours (generally, when I am in a rush and don't need the extra task when arriving or leaving the store). On occassion, when I pointed out a shoplifter leaving with a couple of steak under her coat. The store manager (Quality) brushed me off and said, "Aw, she'll be back some other time. We'll get her then."

    I think, perhaps, markets that took residence in Stuyvesant became overtaxed because it served local residents but also many, many others who traveled from many other neighborhoods because Latina / Quality / Bells et alia was situated on three different bus lines.

    A venue with a variety of prepared food stands (for sit down or take out meals) along with a market could be ideal.

  4. kelly

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 8th 2007, 15:33

    Local rumor has it that the owner of the Tops on Niagara St. has been calling former employees who were recommended by the former management to see if they would be interested in returning to work there under new ownership.

    I haven't noticed a sale or lease sign on the building, either, come to think of it.

  5. Marti

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 11th 2007, 09:48

    Zimm -- your vision is exceptional. What a boon your market concept would be to this community. And I also agree that it needs to include a unique food market, perhaps as described by upright citizen.

    As a mailbox lessee (actually times two - both Buffalo Old Home Week and Buffalo Heritage reside at 266 Elmwood Ave!) and a brand new resident of upper Mariner (and thrilled to be in this fabulous neighborhood!), I have a great at stake personally re this prime chunk of real estate. I will be looking for ways to join you and the others who have commented on your post in influencing the destiny of a tragically underutilized asset.

  6. kanijc11

    0 ratings12345
    Jun 19th 2007, 12:42

    I know for pretty much a fact that the old Latina's Foodland on Elmwood Avenue is becoming another Tops location. I worked at Latina's from the time they opened, May 2005 up until January of 2007. I still keep in contact with various ex co-workers and one of them just told me this 2 days ago. Her husband is taking care of re-hiring alot of the good employees from Latina's to open either a Tops market or another grocery store. But! Regardless, there is going to be a grocery store occupying 250 elmwood avenue sometime this Summer.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links