“Buffalo’s Premier Waterfront Park”… well, it almost was.

While waiting outside of the Mayor’s office yesterday I spent the time examining many of the conceptual master plans that were hanging in the hallway. One of those plans was for LaSalle Park. This particular plan was from the Masiello administration and featured some great ideas that never saw the light of day. It’s too bad… because LaSalle Park is the one park that many city officials and community members keep coming back to as the ideal park when it comes to having all of the right potential. The park is situated between the Erie Basin Marina and the future Sunset Promenade. At this point it is an open slate upon which could be drawn the most intelligent waterfront-friendly plan… like maybe the one shown here?
Unfortunately these plans from past administrations never really make it far once a new administration is in power. Actually, I was surprised to see the series of master plans hanging in the hallway period. The LaSalle Plan includes the relocation of the Colonel Ward Pumping Station, which would then become a (proposed) industrial heritage museum. A beautiful midway runs right through the center of the park and the interruptive park road becomes a winding boulevard that takes visitors past all of the useful amenities. The sloping ‘naturalized shoreline’ sounds wonderful… much nicer than that steel wall that is currently in use. And the ‘multi-purpose lakefront structure’ sounds useful since there really are no useful structures other than the outdoor pavilion, which is incorporated into this rendering. Even Riverwak is incorporated into this functional waterfront park. There are well-positioned playing fields and a picnic grove and even scattered parking lots that you would find at nature-minded state parks. Inland water pools are shown too.
This sounds like just about the best waterfront access one could possibly imagine. And with the redesign of the Peace Bridge? This plan should be revisited because there was obviously a lot of well-spent time and energy that went into it.

As we mentioned in our previous post, we’re in the process of changing the Buffalo Rising site. We’re almost there as we expect to launch the new site on Friday, December 19th.
In the meantime, posting will be light as we log new stories in the new publishing system which will only be viewable when we launch on Friday.
As always, we appreciate our users’ patience as we make this transition but we promise it will be well worth it. With faster load times, a comment view … 




Comment Options
coolrobc
Methinks relocation of the pumping station would be the major stumbling block to this.
Report this
TownLine
The major obstacle impeding all of these great waterfront ideas is the highway system, in this case, the 190. The peace bridge project absolutely has to be designed with waterfront development in mind. As long as the peace bridge remains on the West side of buffalo, the 190 will never be downgraded or removed, thus forever impeding waterfront development. Constructing a new bridge at the current Peace Bridge site or even the Ambassador site will only cause the 190 to remain for at least the next 75-100 years. We have to think a lot more progressively than that. The peace bridge has got to be moved outside of the city boundaries to a location where there is enough open land that the majority of its operations do no occur along the water. Grand Island is the perfect solution. The west side of Grand Island is almost entirely unpopulated, as well as the canadian land across the river and this area offers direct connections to the 190 and QEW (check it out on google earth). I understand there are some high value properties along the water, but we're talking about 10-20 that would be directly affected, at most. A far cry from the tens of thousands who's standards of living are deprived everyday.
If the Peace Bridge location is moved outside the city, then there is no reason why the 190 can not be downgraded to a parkway IMMEDIATELY. This opens up MILES of waterfront land for development, and gives the West side neighborhoods direct access to the water - can you imagine how those neighborhoods would come roaring back?! Property tax revenue skyrocketing for the city. LaSalle and Front Parks would be the premier open space in the city. Right now, you can hardly even get to them.
We have got to get out of our old ways of thinking, that the Peace Bridge will always be where it is, and do whats truly right for the city and the region. Its such a no-brainer, if only people weren't so resistant to change.
Report this
flyguy
And here is the problem. One administration cant seem to recognize progressive efforts to create positive change and pick up where the previous administration left off. Regions cannot develop within a 4 year term of office, large scale improvements cannot always happen within 4 years. It doesnt take a rocket scientist to recognize that this area has been trying to redevelop its waterfront and create respectable public access points for many years and yet exciting new plans as this one are floated out there and create interest and tease the public but by the end of political term they end up becoming nothing more than wall art to be admired as the new administration picks up a new cause that doesnt have enough time to go anywhere.
Report this
bradon
A plan isn't worth the paper it is drawn on, unless action is taken. The problem with past plans is not the changing of the guard, it is the lack of action while the current administration is in place. We fall for these grandiose schemes and plans all the time; yet we still sit with an undeveloped waterfront and a struggling downtown core.
Every administration has made promises about the waterfront, dating back to the 60s, but it still remains under-utilized and under-developed. How many 'Master Plans' exist in City Hall? How many newspaper reports have highlighted the great things that could be done in Buffalo.
It is up to the public to hold officials accountable for our future. The problem is that we are so fucking naive and accepting that we vote the same people into office, year after year, and accept the same political appointees, year after year, and vote our particular party line ticket, year after year, and yet we expect something to change? Seriously, the problem with Buffalo is US! The community that elects politicians and accepts mediocre results and inactivity from them.
This plan is no better or worse than any other plan, they are all the same... just nice looking pictures and words on expensive paper. One of these days, we will actually make something from them, but until then they make great decorations for City Hall.
Report this
chiknlil
Great, move the Peace Bridge to the suburbs and make Grand Island a logistics hub for WNY. Great idea people!
Here is a great idea, move all the businesses to the suburbs and turn Buffalo into one huge waterfront / skate / bike trail / dog park with a lot of really silly museums.
Report this
TownLine
What businesses benefit from close proximity to the peace bridge? Duty Free??? The city does not benefit from the peace bridge to any amount even remotely comparable to opening up that waterfront land. Any business that would greatly benefit, probably requires massive truck access that would be better suited in another regional location anyhow.
Report this
Denizen
Leave the Peace Bridge. But downgrade it to a passenger vehicle-only crossing. That way, the highway won't be needed for all those truck anymore since they will be forced to cross elsewhere.
Report this
RonR
Very interesting point about plans and ideas going dead when a new administration comes to town. We really need to circumvent this. In San Diego, there is something called CCDC. It is a public, non-profit corporation created by the City of San Diego to staff and implement Downtown redevelopment projects and programs. While the positions are appointed by the mayors office to 3 year terms, once a part of CCDC, they do not work for the mayor.
In California there is a redevelopment law that provides cities and counties with the authority, scope and financial means to stimulate the mitigation of blighting conditions in urban areas. The law outlines procedures to determine what development, reconstruction and rehabilitation is needed and desirable. It also defines the financial tools, legal authority and citizen participation necessary to successfully implement adopted plans.
Buffalo does things a little different. Instead of creating a set of guidelines that create the parameters for development, projects are done on a one to one basis with heavy politicking involved EVERY TIME. Instead of having a city wide development arm that can work on the greater picture, every project get a different agency and agenda.
Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation
Buffalo Economic Renaissance Corporation
City of Buffalo Urban Renewal Agency
Buffalo Niagara Enterprise
Buffalo Niagara Partnership
Buffalo Urban Development Corporation
While some of these groups have good intentions and others are just places to get "supporters" a job once you get into office, the fact of the matter is THERE ARE WAY TOO MANY COOKS IN THE KITCHEN. We need one body that has jurisdiction over the entire city. If the county wants to work with Buffalo, one meeting. If Niagara county wants to work with Buffalo, one meeting. I am not sure on how all of these groups get funding but regardless of how they get funding, it is a waste of money. Merge them all into one group.
Report this
Sexy_Beast
-Even though the pumping station might be a tough one, there is no reason that the rest of this plan should not be adopted. The fact is that each administration has defferent ideas that the previous one. RonR is spot on with his idea. LaSalle park has so much potential! -Me
Report this
RonR
I know some people are going to jump on me for this but.....
I would like to see the 190 buried from Porter Ave north to Vermont Street. Essentially the section that fronts Front Park.
Next, I would call for the demo of everything West of Niagara Street from Vermont Street north to Massachusetts Ave. In this area place a new terminal and turn a rounds for the 190 with a focus of placing traffic on Niagara Street.
Next, is connect to the high speed rail line coming from Toronto with the Connecticut Street armory being converted into the main station. From here, run a second line on the Metro to Lafayette Square connecting to the existing line.
Next, demo the Redwood Village and relocate the residents elsewhere in the city. This would create a large track of open land at the footsteps of downtown, lined to the west by Niagara and to the east by LaSalle Park. To the north there is a cutoff for the 190 on ramps and the south is the new Health Now complex. This would be a perfect way to expand upon the growth of the Canal district and recent waterfront high rises.
Report this
chris69
No, think that we have an enormous opportunity to think bigger and it begins: 1) by opposing the second Peace Bridge or expansion of the existing plaza. I do not support the demolition of more homes and businesses to expand the present plaza in any way shape or form
2) Lets come up with a plan that would in effect create a wharf district from the Peace Bridge all the way to Michigan Street incorporating Front Park, LaSalle Park, Erie Basin Marina, the Naval Park, the Western Terminus, Bass Pro and the DL&W.
3) Reconnect the former streets from Massachusetts to Erie back ... connect them all to a waterfront promenade which would re-invigorate the west village and the westside.
4) It wouldnt hurt to contemplate bringing back the demolished Fort and the demolished DL&W concourse.
5) It wouldnt hurt to consider reactivating the Belt-Line. This becomes increasingly justified as the area bounded by the belt line continues to grow in density: HealthNow, Waterfront Tower, Bass Pro, Buffalo State, Central Terminal, Larkin District are all growing.
6) It wouldnt hurt to add a few rotaries and maybe reconstruct the fountains from the PAN AM for the cneter pieces for the rotaries....it wouldht hurt to incorporate some of the old PAN AM gateways either. Its absolutely amazing how few truly classic fountains Buffalo has....
7) Please no parks....we can easily incorporate a walkable waterfront promenade with a wharf with housing, office and commercial development.
Report this
tonyarmani
What it really boils down to is Buffalo needs less politicians in office and more businessmen calling the shots
Report this
STEEL
This prominent park is in a most fantastic location and is in the most deplorable condition. To not take advantage of this asset is a sin. It should be converted to a State Park and treated accordingly.
The first thing that needs to be done is to link the roadway to the Waterfront Village neighborhood and have these people start to take ownership of their neighborhood park and their city. The faux suburban cu de sac must be eliminated.
Report this
anothersaab
just tear the Peace Bridge down. we don't need anymore sneaky canadians coming onto our land!
Report this