Don’t Pick on the Little Guy

On today’s agenda for Buffalo’s Preservation Board is an issue of David against Goliath.
Buffalo State College has submitted a request to demolish a fine little house they own at 649 Grant Street. Built in the mid-19th century, and expanded in the back over the years in classic telescope fashion, this house nestles against much larger houses, including classic Buffalo doubles, built much later. Its size allows for a tree, welcoming front yard, and even sidewalk, which its larger neighbors don’t enjoy.
Bob Franke of the Grant-Ferry Association said, “If Buffalo State has a coherent plan for this area that they'd like to present to the community for open discourse, I have no difficulty in discussing the demolition of 649 Grant Street. Absent such a plan, I am vigorously against the demolition of any viable structures. 649 Grant is indeed a nice little house. It makes a valiant attempt to lend a pleasant look to an otherwise unpleasant environment created by Buff State's parking lots and the rest of the residential structures in this particular area.”
According to Harvey Garrett, the Preservation Board will most likely ask for a stay on the demolition in the hopes of getting Buffalo State to move the building—if a nearby spot can be found—rather than demolish it.
This charming Italianate house reminds me of some of the cottages in the Little Summer neighborhood and several other places on the west side. Because of the small size of the houses, some of those neighborhoods have come to be distinguished by the picturesque gardens developed around them, which we enjoy on GardenWalk. If saved from the bulldozer and moved, I look forward to visiting this house in its new “home” on a future GardenWalk. Do you have a new “home” for this house?
The Beatles said, “I get by with a little help from my friends.” Hopefully, with a little help from a friendly preservation board, and a cooperative Buffalo State, this house—a friendly presence on Grant Street for over a century—will get by to see another century.
This issue will be discussed at the Buffalo Preservation Board, Thursday, December 11, at 3PM, Room 901, City Hall. Also on the agenda will be over thirty demolitions proposed by the City of Buffalo.
Get Connected: Buffalo Preservation Board

As we mentioned in our previous post, we’re in the process of changing the Buffalo Rising site. We’re almost there as we expect to launch the new site on Friday, December 19th.
In the meantime, posting will be light as we log new stories in the new publishing system which will only be viewable when we launch on Friday.
As always, we appreciate our users’ patience as we make this transition but we promise it will be well worth it. With faster load times, a comment view … 




Comment Options
comptart_lws
let me guess… they want to use the lot for parking? that would be verse and chapter out of the D'Youville playbook. I agree with Bob Franke. Show the master plan.
Report this
Joshua
I've said it before and I'll say it again, Buffalo State College needs to build a parking ramp on the site of an existing parking lot. The parking ramp should be 3 or 4 stories. There is NO need to continue to pave over green lots. The only difference between Buffalo State and D'Youville is probably money, the land issue is really the same. Maybe even D'Youville should put up a 2 or 3 story parking ramp. Also, Buffalo State College should expand into the HH Richardson complex, for office and classroom space. Again, there are already building built, the state should recognize this and, thus utilize the space.
Report this
EricOak
Don't let them get away with this.
Report this
RaChaCha
Update: credit to Bob Franke for the entry image - and thanks, Bob, for the great quote.
Report this
blackrocklifer
This would be an easy one to move. (minus the additions)
Report this
distas
how about some dorms on this lot???
Report this
Buffalo21stcentury
I think everyone is wrong on this house. If it was in a residential neighborhood then it would be different but Grant, Rees...is a commercial district.
Now I agree that Buffalo State needs to present a plan before they go demolishing Now I agree that Buffalo State needs a parking ramp 3-4 stories
But the bigger picture is that Buffalo and the Westside/Black Rock area is losing millions upon millions of dollars because Buffalo State would rather turn down 10,000 student applicants per year than expand Buffalo State and the preservation board standing up for this house only justifies Howard in her recalcitrance and do nothing, accomplish nothing obstructionism.
These houses should go so Buffalo State can build a parking garage, dormatories, stadiums, baseball fields, tracks, small busines incubators, bookstores, coffee shops, teachers offices, etc (basically build up non-academic buildings off the core campus).
None of the non-academic buildings I mentioned should be located on the core campus!!!! The core campus is already landlocked...and if it is to have the future growth to add 10,000 students then its core campus must be reserved for academic buildings....particularly since Buffalo State is increasing its partnerships with UB (particularly in technology based areas).
It is critical to Grant Street, Amherst, Forest, Niagara, Tonawanda, etc for Buffalo State to take these homes and get them demolished so the campus can be expanded. I dont think the preservationists should stand in Buffalo States way on this house or the other houses on Rees and Grant....but I do think its fair to ask Buffalo State what their plan is for Rees and Grant for the next 5 years!
Report this
Buffalo21stcentury
Lets just put it this way...everyone should write off the homes between Forest and the Scajaquada from on Rees all the way to West.
By sacrificing the homes in this area to Buffalo State we can secure the homes north of Amherst and South of Forest.
Again the big problem goes right back to Howard and her lack of accomplishments. A 5 or 10 year plan would put out to the community the future of Buffalo State Campus. If the community knew about how and where Buffalo State intends to expand its campus then the preservationists along with the community would buy in and shut up. I think everyone would love to see property values on the westside and blackrock stabilize if not increase because of an expanded Buffalo State, especially if an expansion included a small business incubator park and dormatories where employees and students could patronize apartments and businesses on Forest, Grant and Amherst to name a few.
Report this
sonyactivision
It's a simple wood frame structure so Buff State should have no problem paying for its move .
Report this
RaChaCha
Update (from Tim Tielman):
"Thursday at the Preservation Board meeting, I introduced two motions, and the Board approved, to recommend Italianate cottage at 649 Grant St. not be demo'd, and to undertake preparation of a landmark nomination. Normally, the Board has 30 days upon which to act on an app, then, depending on its recommendation, the city can issue or not issue a demo app. The nomination process leaves the timeline more open-ended; buying time to work out a solution.
The board received letters urging preservation of building from Grant-Ferry Assoc., Gregory Tanski, and Campaign for Greater Buffalo."
Note: Greg Tanski is the co-chair of the Citizen's Advisory Committee for the Richardson/Olmsted Complex.
Report this