Girls' Rugby Grows in Buffalo

Over the past several years, girls' rugby has experienced steady growth in Buffalo and Western New York. One of the hotbeds of the sport locally is City Honors School, which recently won the girls rugby state championship.
Rugby is a fast-moving, free-flowing game that is often called a combination of football and soccer. Like football, it’s a full-contact sport; like soccer, it’s fast-moving and free-flowing. Players attempt to carry the ball into the opposition's end zone (actually called the in-goal area), which results in a “try”, as it is called. A try counts as 5 points, and a successful place kick afterwards another 2 points. The most distinctive aspect of rugby is the scrum, a formation that resembles both teams forming a football huddle and pushing against each other.

Coached by CHS social studies teacher John McTigue along with Mike Hodgins of the Genesee Rugby Football Club and President of New York State rugby, the team recently captured the New York State Rugby U-19 Championship by defeating the Fairport Girls, 46-0, in Delaware Park. Fairport, which had been undefeated, was ranked #1. City Honors’ dominant performance was particularly impressive in light of the fact that, early in the season, the Centaurs had lost at Fairport, 47-5. (Later, in May, the teams played to a scoreless tie at the Northeast Rugby Union's territorial playoffs.)
In 2004 City Honors became the first girls' team in the Buffalo area to play a high school rugby game. Today, there are also teams from Kenmore West, Kenmore East, Orchard Park, East Aurora, North Tonawanda and Grand Island.
So why is girls rugby growing? According to CHS player Ayla Axeloons, one big reason is that many girls enjoy the physical aspect of the sport. She added that, even though rugby is as physical as football, rugby players wear very little—if any—protective equipment. Injuries, from broken noses to broken legs, are an accepted part of the sport.
CHS co-captain Cailin West admitted that the sport often looks like “organized chaos,” but a good rugby team is fifteen people, each with a different role, working together in with precision and coordination. Rugby is a team sport at its core, as it requires the commitment and dedication of all the players, not just a couple of star players. The trust and camaraderie that develops as a result helps make rugby an enjoyable experience for the players.

Axeloons agreed, saying, “In other sports you don’t rely on your teammates as much, but in rugby it’s all about the team.”
Another attraction of rugby is that, whatever your body type, there’s a position that is suited to it. Rugby is also a sport that is readily accessible to everyone. While it can take years to learn many of the nuances of rugby, it is not unheard of for a new player to step in and make an immediate contribution.
Rugby can be a difficult sport to play, but the growth of local high school programs is giving many girls a great opportunity to enjoy the unique aspects of this sport.

As we mentioned in our previous post, we’re in the process of changing the Buffalo Rising site. We’re almost there as we expect to launch the new site on Friday, December 19th.
In the meantime, posting will be light as we log new stories in the new publishing system which will only be viewable when we launch on Friday.
As always, we appreciate our users’ patience as we make this transition but we promise it will be well worth it. With faster load times, a comment view … 




Comment Options
Lifer
To say that broken noses and legs are an "accepted" part of the game is not only incorrect but could be construed as dangerous to its growth and popularity. As much as injuries may occur, it has been shown through a recently completed study that high-school rugby has less injuries and more importantly, much less "catestrophic" head injuries than are seen in other, more popular high school athletics (i.e. football and lacrosse). With proper coaching and technique, the risk of these sorts of injuries is mitigated to the lowest possible rate. The fact remains that in most other contact, or concussive athletics, the athlete is protected by a mass of hard plastic and metal. The unfortunate side effect of the use of these materials is the athelete using their body as a projectile - which is much more dangerous than having no equipment at all. Having two individuals with no equipment make it necesary for both athletes to consider their own well being - whether receving or delivering a hit.
Report this
allfit
Thomas - Rugby is not anywhere near as physical as football, the amount of force, speed, severity, and strength involved in football are not seen in rugby. A well conditioned football player is not usually able to adjust to the lower impact and lack of force present in rugby games. There is something to be said for helmets and shoulder pads, but ask anyone who has played football, they only work to distribute the force enough to keep you from getting seriously hurt. That much force placed against an unprotected body would easily break bones and cause severe contusions and concussions. To think that a football or lacrosse team is made up of only a few star players exposes your ignorance of the sport. These sports require a level of team work that is not seen in rugby, which is far more unorganized than either of the other sports.
You are obviously very knowledgeable about rugby but uninformed about the sports that you compare it to. I suggest you play lacrosse and football a few times before making ignorant comparisons. I have played all three sports, as well as soccer, baseball, and hockey at various levels, and I can say that rugby was probably the easiest to pick up and master.
Report this
galaxyjay
allfit - I'm sorry did you say easy to "pickup" and "master" ...whom did you play for? A pickup game does not count as actually playing for a team. Rugby is an extremely team oriented sport so if you think differently then perhaps you are the ignorant.
...Did you really say that Rugby is not as team oriented as lacrosse? ...Really?
Report this
allfit
I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings with my comments. Yes, Rugby is relatively easy to pick-up and relatively easy to master. I played rugby for two leagues in Boston and for a league in DC, total experience was probably 8 or 9 years. I picked it up after graduating from college, where I played football at the I-A level for 5 years and lacrosse at the club level for 2 of those years.
I believe that this perception may be supported by the author's comment: While it can take years to learn many of the nuances of rugby, it is not unheard of for a new player to step in and make an immediate contribution.
All of the sports mentioned above are team oriented, my objection was to the comment that football and lacrosse are primarily focused on a few star players, that just isn't the case. You can rely on the actions and athleticism of one or two key players in rugby far more than you can in lacrosse or football.
So, have you played all of these sports at a competitive level or are you just being a difficult rugby player who feels that this is the hardest hitting and most competitive sport in the world? I know a couple of ultimate frisbee players who may disagree with your limited point of view.
Report this
heathersmiles
Hey, don't knock Ultimate Frisbee!
Report this