In Memory Of James Shields

In Memory Of James Shields

Story Options

There are certain street corners in Buffalo that can make you stop and think. Have you ever noticed the small blue signs attached to random lamp standards that mark dedications to police officers who have died in the line of duty? At the corner of Delaware and Bryant there is on the reads, "This route is dedicated in memory of police officer James Shields - October 30, 2002." James Shields had been in hot pursuit of two bank robbers, along with his partner Officer Kimberly Monteforte, when their car slammed into a tree on Delaware. James Shields, 36-years old and a seven-year veteran, did not survive the crash.

Ever since that horrific day, someone has spent an incredible amount of time making sure that the memory of James Shields lives on. For the last five years I have noticed that the base of the tree has been transformed into a shrine for the fallen officer. I've seen Holiday decorations, and American flags, and ribbons, and keepsakes... one thing is for certain - someone has made sure that James's spirit is always taken care of. For the occasional passer-by that happens to stop at that corner light and look around, you will see how lovely that tree looks. The stone that marks the site (right now) reads, "If love could have saved you, you would have lived forever." Even though most people who drive that route never knew James Shields, the collective debt of gratitude of all those who pass by that tree is very powerful.

prometheus233.com half banner

What Others Have To Say

  1. luluofnorth

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 08:52

    my life slows a bit when I pass this tree -- humbling -- thanks, QE

  2. fill

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 11:30

    These two officers were not using seat belts which could well have saved Officer Shields' life. His partner's excuse was absurd - She claimed that they didn't use seat belts because they have to get out of the car fast when responding to emergencies ! How long does it take to unsnap a seat belt ? It seems to me that this law applies to everyone and that even the police are not in a position to obey the laws they feel like obeying.

  3. Frankster

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 11:59

    Here's another article about that particular roadside shrine:

    .

  4. Frankster

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 12:00

    Whoops, BuffaloRising rejected my hyperlink. Here it is unlinked: http://buffaloreport.com/021115shrines.html

  5. HelenWheels

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 12:08

    Someone calls 911 - they saw a man holding you up on the street - he has a gun at your head - police are dispatched - the seatbelt jams when an officer is getting out of the car - the robber uses this time to shoot you and the cop then turns to run and get away. Yes, I know it wouldn't happen 99% of the time - but for that other 1% it can and has in other states. Show a little respect instead of tearing memories apart. Remember, he swerved to avoid injuring another person/vehicle - it took his life, protecting anothers. Maybe a little class is also in order here.

  6. kelly

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 4th 2007, 12:57

    I have mixed feelings about those roadside shrines. Years ago, there was a car accident with a fatality on the road near a friend's home. People turned a tree on her family's lawn by the road into a shrine. So every single day, leaving for school, going to the grocery store, they were reminded of someone being killed outside their house. And in most cases people who leave items don't think about what happens to them after, so her parents had to deal with rotting stuffed animals left in the elements for months, dead flowers, etc, feeling disrespectful throwing them out, but not wanting what the WNY weather had turned into quite literally garbage blowing all over their lawn.

    I don't know, my first thought seeing them is "how sad" but the second is always "and how awful for the people living there to be reminded of a tragedy they had nothing to do with every time they look out a window or go outside."

  7. DJK

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 5th 2007, 12:52

    If I remember correctly, these officers were chasing after a perpetrator who after a non-violent convenience store robbery had boarded a CITY BUS. You know, slow moving, set route?

    I think it's terrible that this officer died, particularly in the line of duty, but this cannot be one of the department's proudest moments. Didn't another officer get struck and killed the same year when running across Route 33? I value the Police, and honestly don't want to think of them risking their lives regularly. Thank God nobody else was hurt.

    And when my small children ask me what those flowers represent, I won't be able to resist making it a poignant seat-belt lesson.

  8. Geomike

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 5th 2007, 14:16

    Excellent post Queenseyes - I feel a little bit of sorrow everytime I pass this tree. Sure we should all wear seatbelts, and the Police should lead by example. But, before we cast stones from our glass houses remember these few things: 1. Police receive specialized training in driving at high speeds for their own safety and to prevent injury to bystanders (which they acocmplished here). So it's not just your neighbor getting in a car and driving 50 MPH down Delaware because he's an idiot - it's a professional, with a lot of training, who chose a dnagerous job because he or she wants to protect you, whom they have never met. BTW - not wearing seat belts is fairly common for law enforcement who are often in and out of the car, and for our military servicemen and women. It lets them get out fo the car quickly - in the military it's called a "combat stop" when the passenger gets out before the car totally stops, so they can take off running if needed, to help us civilians. 2. Generally someone with a gun who robs a sotre, is dangerous, so if they got on the metro bus I was on with a gun, I'd be pretty thrilled to see a cop car come flying to meet the slow moving bus to be sure said thug doesn't come after me next on the bus. 3. Until you've spent time with the cops in the tough neighborhoods of Buffalo at night with the occassional less than rational criminal (and nice people do actually outnumber the thugs in these tough neighborhoods), let's at least show some respect for those who lost their life trying to protect the rest of us ingrates who enjoy living in a pretty safe city. And no I'm not a cop, nor related to one, nor a city employee or union member. I'm just someone offended by some of the comments here who thought I at least owed them the courtesy of a brief defense on their behalf. Nice way to ruin an othewise really thoughtful and heartfelt post. Let's try to keep some civility and respect for our fewllo human beings. If our mission is to make Buffalo a better place, at a minimum it's got start with how treat one another.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links