Welcome to NIMBY Court

Welcome to NIMBY Court

Story Options

Don’t like what your neighbor is proposing for their property? Buy it. That is what just went down on Rumsey Lane. Sue Ann Simonin received City approvals to tear down a 1940’s ranch at 25-27 Rumsey (entry image) in anticipation of constructing her dream home last year. Her plans for the new residence ran into a buzzsaw of neighborhood opposition but finally received the necessary approvals to build in April. On Thursday she sold the site to an adjoining property owner. Price? A whopping $650,000.

Simonin purchased the property in June 2007, paying $237,500 for the 1,465 sq.ft. Rufus Meadows-designed home built in 1948. Her plans for a new, larger residence drew neighborhood angst who claimed the design was incompatible in height, scale, massing and materials of nearby homes. The existing house was demolished.

Thursday, Think Solutions, Inc., an entity owned by Robert B. Skerker, purchased the 70’ x 94’ property assessed at $150,000. Skerker, Chairman and CEO of Robinson Home Products, lives next door.

rumsey.png

prometheus233.com half banner

What Others Have To Say

  1. EricOak

    1 ratings12345
    Aug 30th 2008, 00:28

    There is a new house going up on Rumsey Lane--is that part of this lot? I'd love to see all the houses on Rumsey Lane go to House Heaven--they're sad. One of the most dramatic mansions in Buffalo sat on this site.

  2. pegger

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 30th 2008, 04:05

    I had heard that it was being torn down to make room for a tennis court and/or pool for an adjacent property at a sale price of $124,000 a few years back. Later, I saw it on the MLS fro more. Now it is a seemingly outrage My question then was: How did this ordinary typical ranch style house get built in that neighborhood in the first place? Why the steep price? Location, location, location. The land is worth it to the buyer, That simple.

  3. vgs

    1 ratings12345
    Aug 30th 2008, 07:31

    And folks here often wonder who in poor Buffalo can even afford a 300K condo, now we have people paying $650K for a lot

  4. gaustad

    1 ratings12345
    Aug 31st 2008, 23:49

    this guy is out of his mind paying that kind of change for a lot.

  5. MichaelB

    0 ratings12345
    Sep 3rd 2008, 11:51

    I would like to see what was being proposed by Simonin and her architect for the new house/home. Why would the neighbor have such opposition?

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links