The City's Holiday Two-Day Free Parking Plan

 The City's Holiday Two-Day Free Parking Plan

Story Options

It's one of the topics that I love arguing with people about - the apparent lack of parking in the city's commercial districts. If you've ever traveled to cities like Boston or Toronto, then you know how difficult it can be to park your car in a commercial district (or any district for that matter). Buffalonians must learn that as the commercial districts continue to grow, parking spaces will in turn be depleted. Are parking woes really that bad around here? If more people shop in the city, it might mean that a walk from a parking space to a destination will be longer. Is it that big of a deal? Or are people spoiled by the massive amount of parking spaces at the malls? Even the malls require a short hike to get to the front door... and from there one must get to the shopping destination of his or her choice. In the end, a walk is a walk and I'd rather be walking out in the fresh air in an urban commercial district.

This Holiday season, Mayor Brown is requesting that parking meter collections be suspended for two days prior to Christmas. That would mean that on Tuesday, December 23rd and Wednesday, December 24th, drivers would be able to park for free on commercial streets such as Hertel Avenue. There are mixed emotions as to whether this sort of idea is a good one. On the one hand, it's nice to be able to save a few quarters when parking. It's also good to know that you don't have to rush back to your car when the meter expires. On the flipside, residents and store employees have been known to take advantage of these types of opportunities. What a break it is to be able to park the car and not have to worry about it for a couple days. Years ago, Elmwood business owners fought to install meters along certain blocks in order to keep a constant flow of customers circulating in and out of the shops. If there is slow turnaround at the parking meters, then that might be reflected in the number a cash register sales.

Free parking is a nice idea, but if you think that there is a parking problem now, just wait until you don't have to throw quarters in the meter.

Rock Harbor

What Others Have To Say

  1. Sal

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 14th 2008, 16:05

    Time limits can be enforced without charging for parking.

  2. urbansoul

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 14th 2008, 16:15

    There is SOOOOOOO much parking in Buffalo.

  3. Rebecca

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 14th 2008, 18:06

    A drop in price leads to an increase in demand. No one will be able to park and they'll be forced to leave and go to the mall.

    The meters make sure there is turnover. People will park all day and new shoppers will have nowhere to go. This is a bad idea, to say nothing of the lost revenue.

  4. littleacorn

    1 ratings12345
    Dec 14th 2008, 20:41

    For the last five or six years I have visited Bar Harbor, Maine. According to its tourist bureau and publications they have about three millions tourists visit the area,mostly during the summer. I could make a phone call for a fact check but I would estimate that about 75% to 80% of the parking is FREE along the main streets and side streets of the town. Bar Harbor even provides FREE, note that FREE parking lots for the tourists, businesses, and anyone else visiting. They have one rule as far as I know and that is,you are limited to a 2 HOUR time limit for a parking spot for many spots. There are hundreds of stores, restaurants and other associated tourists businesses there. This last summer I violated the rule, overstayed my time limit and was given a ten ($10) dollar parking ticket that did not double and double again every few days if it was paid late. I was two days late. Check accepted for ten dollars. Bar Harbor has density and choice of tourist attractions. Bar Harbor's ticket was more than what I would call a nuisance amount but the remainder of the parking policy is a reminder that they are tourist friendly. Buffalo if it could would triple the original ticket and double it every few days so the politicians downtown could get their share of the money. Of course that ticket penalty money is money that is not then being spent in the stores. So much for the short sighted business owners in Buffalo who insist on high parking fees. If you believe that parking fees are not part of Buffalo's problem then try place a fee on every parking spot at malls, suburban businesses etc. Make the penalty punitive and double it every ten days. I am always amazed at the lack of common sense and the powers of observation in some commentators.

  5. clafleur

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 15th 2008, 08:54

    I think the issue here isn't the policy, but the people who abuse the system (locals and employees). How idiotic do you have to be to sabotage a program that is designed to bring money and people to your stores and areas. Great program, stupid people.

  6. littleacorn

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 15th 2008, 09:49

    What do you mean abuse the system? Why would any intelligent business person allow his employees or himself the luxury of parking in front of the business for the entire day thus depriving the customers of a convenient parking spot? As I said if I give the money to the politicians either in the form of parking fees or tickets, then I am not spending it in the store. This isn't a program, it is only lasting two days. It is more of a burp. It seems to me that City Hall is admitting that customers prefer cheap or free parking. They are afraid to change the policy that has made parking a revenue stream in the city budget. If you want to see how much the city collects then check out the budget on the City of Buffalo's website.

  7. clafleur

    0 ratings12345
    Dec 15th 2008, 10:26

    I'm referring to the part of the article that said "On the flipside, residents and store employees have been known to take advantage of these types of opportunities. What a break it is to be able to park the car and not have to worry about it for a couple days....." littleacorn, you're right, no business owner would allow that, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen, especially by the residents. Free parking would be great, but like you said about Bar Harbor, a free lot would be much better than free roadside parking.

  8. sbrof

    1 ratings12345
    Dec 15th 2008, 13:23

    Paying 25 cents or a dollar for parking is not going to bring extra people to shop in Buffalo. This is nothing more than the same mentality that demolished 50% of our downtown for plentiful parking. We can't compete on the parking front to the suburbs. I don't know why we even try. All it does is create false hope. If people know they have to trow a quarter in the meter.. fine it's easy and cheap. The uncertainty of their hours, the days of operation, the location of the lots, what about broken meters... These are the things that aggravate and push people away.

    Also safety is probably the biggest factor for most people coming into the for any reason. Forcing the cops OUT of their cushy little cars and actually walking the beat would throw them in the face of both criminals and the public. When a cop car wizzes by, a criminal knows he just have to wait 30 seconds to go about doing whatever he was doing. A cop walking the beat is going to be a problem for 10-20 minute until he is out of hearing range... That is a safe feeling. A cop in a car who will be 1/2 mile away in 30 seconds is not a feeling of safety.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links